Secure Talk podcast | by Strike Graph

"It's a Piece of Junk": A Cybersecurity Professor's Case Against Tor

Written by Strike Graph Team | Nov 17, 2026, 8:32:06 PM

One of the most respected voices in online child safety research just called Tor "a piece of junk" — and he has the math to back it up. Brian Levine — Distinguished Professor at UMass Amherst, ACM Fellow, and Director of the UMass Cybersecurity Institute — joins Justin Beals to explain why two decades of fighting online child exploitation convinced him that one of tech's most trusted anonymity tools does more harm than good.

Chapters

00:00 Levine challenges common claims about Tor
02:13 The peer-to-peer research that revealed online abuse
05:36 Rescue Lab and safety by design
07:41 Investigating with public data, lawfully
10:40 Why university research helps - and its funding limits
14:30 Peer-to-peer networks, moderation, and accountability
16:27 Tor Browser versus Tor Onion Services
18:53 Levine’s critique of Tor’s protections and governance
22:38 How online platforms are exploited
25:50 Who controls Tor, and why terminology matters
31:24 Privacy for whistleblowers and dissidents
36:18 AI-generated abuse and designing safer platforms

📝 Summary

Levine's core claim lands hard for a security audience: cryptography isn't the weak point — governance is. "You don't break the encryption of Tor. You disrupt its routing through the network. And it's a very weak system," he explains, arguing the Tor Project has known about documented abuse for years without meaningfully addressing it.

For CISOs and compliance leaders, the takeaway extends beyond Tor: any platform — anonymity tool, marketplace, or SaaS product — has to be designed assuming bad actors will exploit it. "Safety by design," Levine says, isn't optional anymore.

🔔 Strike Graph builds the compliance infrastructure that turns "safety by design" into practice for defense-industrial-base companies. (www.strikegraph.com)

About the guest: Brian Levine holds a PhD in Computer Engineering (UC Santa Cruz, 1999) and directs the UMass Cybersecurity Institute. Elected ACM Fellow in 2020; sole author of a 2022 NIJ Report to Congress on internet-based crimes against children. Featured in the New York Times, Wall Street Journal, and other major outlets.

Related episodes: 
CMMC Phase 2 suspension: https://youtu.be/V-eiHMJiYbs?si=L82UtGOJSTFynXQG
AI governance with Fran Berman: https://youtu.be/2_iRwe_AUp0?si=hdFv85muCRWQcxNP
Non-human identity with Dan Cinnamon: https://youtu.be/UQKYuKpE6lo?si=Fkvsr8A1mE2GX24S

#CyberSecurity #Compliance #TorNetwork #ChildSafety #AIThreats #DigitalForensics #OnlineSafety #SecureTalk